Skip navigation
Images of the library

Hutchinson Library

New Books and Book Reviews

Junior Book Reviews

The Girl With The Broken Wing

Reviewed by Jane

Hunwick Primary School

This story is about: Two twins hear a strange tapping noise on their window and they open it to find a girl with a broken wing. They try to fix the wing.

The part I enjoyed most was: When the angle crashes off the window

However, I did not enjoy: Nothing

My score out of ten for this book is: 8

I would recommend this book to age group, because: 8+, because it is a good adventure story.



Reviewed by Beth B

Hunwick Primary School

This story is about: Twins go to bed and see an angel. They go to school and when they come back she is throwing paper planes off the roof and their room is a mess with chocolate and pens all over the floor.

The part I enjoyed most was: When they saw her on the roof.

However, I did not enjoy: The end.

My score out of ten for this book is: 3

I would recommend this book to age group, because: 7+, because it was easy to read.



Reviewed by Chloe

Hunwick Primary School

This story is about: James and Amanda were asleep when they heard a sound like cabbage

The part I enjoyed most was: The angel came.

However, I did not enjoy: I enjoyed all of it.

My score out of ten for this book is: 10

I would recommend this book to age group: Older people



Reviewed by Abbie

Hunwick Primary School

This story is about: Twins who hear a quiet tapping noise like wet cabbage as the author said. They go outside and see a girl with only one wing, so the twins go and help the girl to find her wing.

The part I enjoyed most was: The part when they saw the girl with only one wing.

However, I did not enjoy: The ending wasn't that good

My score out of ten for this book is: 6

I would recommend this book to age group, because: 9+, because it is still a bit of a fairy story.



Reviewed by Laura

Hunwick Primary School

This story is about: It is about twins called James and Amanda, they hear a thump that sounds like a wet cabbage. They go to see and it’s a girl with a broken wing.

The part I enjoyed most was: When the angel banged off the window

However, I did not enjoy: Nothing

My score out of ten for this book is: 8

I would recommend this book to age group, because: 8+, because it’s a fun story



Reviewed by Janane

Hunwick Primary School

This story is about: The twins are in bed and thud rattled the window. Then they heard a knock (a tap) on the window. They opened it and there stood a girl with a broken wing so they let her stay.

The part I enjoyed most was: When the angel crashed on the window

However, I did not enjoy: When Hilary disappeared

My score out of ten for this book is: 7

I would recommend this book to age group: 7 – 12



Click here to see other Junior Book Reviews